Wednesday, August 26, 2009

Dare to Explore?

Language is described as a means of survival in the first chapter of the novel. British English is associated with public success while Trinidadian is associated with the home and family in this chapter. The character in the novel finds it difficult to reach a happy medium between the language she is to speak at home and in the public. The exploration into the double life she is living raises many questions concerning language and identity. At what cost is one willing to give up a native language for the sake of being successful in the public eye? The character finds herself speaking in British English in front of her friends and being laughed at because she pronounced the “th” sound in the word “there”. Each time she uses British English she disconnects more and more with her own language and thus her culture. “The more I succeeded in this role, the more I felt segregated from my peers,” (Dowdy 8). This then raises the question – does a decrease in the use of a native language trigger a loss of identity? As the character disconnects more and more with her family and friends, does she lose a sense of who she is? In the case of the text, the character’s native language was still present, and she demonstrated this when she became the “good girl” in school. When the character was otherwise imitating the English language, the author described it as putting barriers or “chains” on a native language. Do these chains have the power to completely lockup a native language? Once a native language is locked away for some time, is there ever a point when it simply fades away? And at what cost is one willing to explore this?

2 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Response 1
    In Ernie Smith’s essay Ebonics: A Case History, Smith grew up in an environment where people were constantly breaking him down because of the way he spoke; he goes on to prove himself worthy by going to college and doing exceedingly well. Just because Smith spoke Ebonics, people saw this as a way to ridicule and degrade him. His “verbal cripple” was a problem for him in school because teachers would place him in classes set for students that had a basic comprehension. At the end of the essay, we learn that Smith was being held behind all because of his dialect when actually he was more than capable of learning. Once he met someone with a passion for learning, he realized that he too needed to be passionate about his language for it is his identity.
    Ernie Smith struggled to learn a new language while Joanne Kilgour Dowdy struggled in decided which language to leave behind. If Dowdy chooses to leave behind her Trinidadian English, it does not mean that she is losing her identity. Both of her languages contribute to her identity in a unique way; the same works for Smith. Smith’s identity is only strengthened because he will not ever forget the long, hard road from Ebonics to English. Their language transitions only make them stronger. However, in switching language they may eventually lose their native language. This is depressing in a way, but one must remember the journey that these people took to move up in life.

    ReplyDelete